Although the tradition of wearing wedding rings date back to Ancient Egyptian times, in the US, ceremonies where the couple exchanged rings weren’t very common until the 1900s. Prior to this period, only women typically wore a wedding ring to commemorate the marriage. However, with the First World War, soldiers began to wear rings to remember their loved ones while they were away and eventually this turned into the tradition of men wearing wedding rings as we know it today.
For most couples, wedding rings are often the first piece of jewelry that they choose together and it’s the symbol of your marriage and commitment to each other. However, choosing the right wedding rings can be tricky. You may each have different tastes or requirements, and this can influence the type of rings you eventually buy. But the question that most couples ask is:
Do our wedding rings have to match, or can we choose different bands?
Let’s take a look at this question and the three main routes you can take when selecting your wedding bands.
#1 – Matching Bands: For the traditional couple
This is the most traditional way to go about this. Purchasing a matching set of wedding bands signifies the following:
- It’s symbolic of your unity and represents how you’re each a part of a whole.
- It indicates that you have traditional values and take part in these.
- It symbolises your similarity in thinking, tastes and style, which indicates that you’re a perfect match.
Such symbolism is perfect for a couple about to embark on a new chapter together and is appealing for many young people. This is why matching bands is the most popular option when it comes to wedding rings.
If you want to go one step further, you can opt to have a trio bridal set, which includes a matching engagement ring as well, like this 14k yellow gold trio set. This makes it easier to look for matching rings as all the work has already been done for you.
#2 – Different Bands: For the non-conforming couple
This is the non-traditional option that’s increasing in popularity. In today’s world, where individuality and personality are highly valued, this symbolizes:
- You’re both different and have your individuality yet you can work together as a pair.
- You’re secure in your love and trust for each other.
- You both value independence and treading your own path.
Choosing your own wedding bands not only demonstrates your individuality, but it’s also a practical option. There’s no need to feel pressure when shopping as you can opt for what suits you best, as per your appearance and lifestyle. For example, if you spend a lot of time working with heavy machinery, you might opt for a silicone wedding band, while your partner might go for the traditional gold band. In the same way, you can choose a metal color that suits your skin tone like yellow gold for tan or dark skin.
This option gives you and your partner a lot of versatility and flexibility. However, make sure that the both of you are on the same page about choosing completely different rings to avoid ill-feeling and disappointment.
#3 – Complementary Bands: For the perfect compromise
Complementary bands are wedding bands that look good together and have similar elements, but don’t totally match. It’s a compromise between mixing and matching. This is perfect for the couple that want a little similarity in their rings without resorting to completely matching bands. This kind of bands symbolize:
- You’re individual beings with a lot in common making you perfect for each other.
- You value independence and non-conformity but you also value tradition.
- You have similar tastes.
For complementary wedding bands, choose common design elements that link the two rings together, while still keeping them different. There are many ways that this could be done. For example, you could choose two rings of the same metal color but with completely different designs. Another option is to opt for the same engraving on both rings which would tie two totally different rings together. Similar finishes, patterns, colors, metal and design elements are all ways to link two different rings and show the similarity between them.
Which Should I Choose?
Same or Different? By Revolution BA. See this here.
Take a look at some opinions expressed by our readers:
Tilly: I think mismatched rings are more common than matched rings. We loved the contrast of our different rings and how it represented our totally unique styles!
Aubrey: Our rings were completely different because he needed something he could wear at his workshop and I loved rose gold. So he ended up with a silicone band and I bought my shiny rose gold set. It’s an indication of how we work together to find solutions as a whole.
Jordan: I’ve always been very traditional, so it was important to me that our rings matched perfectly. I wanted it to symbolize that we were one. I understand not everyone will see it that way, but for us it was a big deal.
As you can see, there’s arguments that can be made for all three options listed above. At the end of the day, it comes down to what matters to you and your partner, what you value and what you prefer. There’s really no right or wrong answer.
If you’re looking to browse engagement and wedding rings, we recommend starting here.